Holy shit suno is actually impressive as frick. The voices are still a bit robotic and the lyrics are a bit generic if you use gpt to expand them but man... Some of them sound like shit I'd hear on the radio. Which I guess says more about how formulaic modern music is
Because the music industry is notoriously litigious. If there was a music equivalent of Stable Diffusion or Midjourney it would already be sued into oblivion by record labels and cause huge damage to the AI industry.
>Why hasn't there been more development in AI music?
Ignore meme answers like >Because the music industry is notoriously litigious. If there was a music equivalent of Stable Diffusion or Midjourney it would already be sued into oblivion by record labels and cause huge damage to the AI industry
Nobody fricking cares about lawsuits in ai, certainly not cutting edge VC funded to oblivion companies. Openai already got sued 7383 times, nobody gives a shit.
Here's the actual reason:
Music has several magnitude orders more complexity than art if we're comparing creative directions.
Basically your brain works a fricking lot decoding all of that information and triggering all your cutesy neurons.
The following dimensions and aspects are relevant for music: >Time >Individual voices/instrument/FX tracks >Timbre and individual characteristics of those voices >Melodies of those instruments >Rhythm of this instruments >Combination of all of the above, as well as self-referential and intertwining structure of the piece.
HARD MODE >Lyrics in combination with individual characteristics of that instrument (voice of the singer) AND rhythmic and tonal patterns with regard to the other instruments >Emotional aspects of specific melodies, timbres, rhythms
And so on and so on.
Don't forget, all of this is compressed into a single sound wave, which basically makes decoding impossible unless you actually know what went into that Soundwave, or you're a human who has amassed an internal emotional library able to catch all those little references, or just "feel" the music. And if you can't decode, you can't encode, rendering any approaches of modern NNs entirely useless. This is why currently every single music AI either sounds plain shit, or like procedurally generated elevator music.
As of now, this is the only normalgay accepted AI album:
https://plzmakeitruins.bandcamp.com/album/the-head-hurts-but-the-heart-knows-the-truth-3
It's lo-fi electronica with a robot man talking about how shit everything is.
Worth noting that this album was made by an actual musician and record producer (Vegyn) who used AI as a tool to actually make something rather than get mad about it on twitter.
I think if you pursue let alone enjoy AI music you should have a nice day for being such a soulless smooth brain npc of a “person”. I think the same for anyone who partakes in any AI generated content.
Throwing out what attributes make you human, fine. Then to me you are no longer human. Eat shit and die, Black person.
All music in the last decade is "AI developed". Notice how it all becomes stale after 3 months. It's formulaic and optimized to harvest attention for a short period and then become entirely forgotten.
Suno is pretty good tbh. Also israeli labels and their imaginary property
https://app.suno.ai/
Holy shit suno is actually impressive as frick. The voices are still a bit robotic and the lyrics are a bit generic if you use gpt to expand them but man... Some of them sound like shit I'd hear on the radio. Which I guess says more about how formulaic modern music is
There is, you're not paying attention
Because the music industry is notoriously litigious. If there was a music equivalent of Stable Diffusion or Midjourney it would already be sued into oblivion by record labels and cause huge damage to the AI industry.
Eventually we will reach a turning point where whatever copyright issues will be solved
>Why hasn't there been more development in AI music?
Ignore meme answers like
>Because the music industry is notoriously litigious. If there was a music equivalent of Stable Diffusion or Midjourney it would already be sued into oblivion by record labels and cause huge damage to the AI industry
Nobody fricking cares about lawsuits in ai, certainly not cutting edge VC funded to oblivion companies. Openai already got sued 7383 times, nobody gives a shit.
Here's the actual reason:
Music has several magnitude orders more complexity than art if we're comparing creative directions.
Basically your brain works a fricking lot decoding all of that information and triggering all your cutesy neurons.
The following dimensions and aspects are relevant for music:
>Time
>Individual voices/instrument/FX tracks
>Timbre and individual characteristics of those voices
>Melodies of those instruments
>Rhythm of this instruments
>Combination of all of the above, as well as self-referential and intertwining structure of the piece.
HARD MODE
>Lyrics in combination with individual characteristics of that instrument (voice of the singer) AND rhythmic and tonal patterns with regard to the other instruments
>Emotional aspects of specific melodies, timbres, rhythms
And so on and so on.
Don't forget, all of this is compressed into a single sound wave, which basically makes decoding impossible unless you actually know what went into that Soundwave, or you're a human who has amassed an internal emotional library able to catch all those little references, or just "feel" the music. And if you can't decode, you can't encode, rendering any approaches of modern NNs entirely useless. This is why currently every single music AI either sounds plain shit, or like procedurally generated elevator music.
As of now, this is the only normalgay accepted AI album:
https://plzmakeitruins.bandcamp.com/album/the-head-hurts-but-the-heart-knows-the-truth-3
It's lo-fi electronica with a robot man talking about how shit everything is.
Worth noting that this album was made by an actual musician and record producer (Vegyn) who used AI as a tool to actually make something rather than get mad about it on twitter.
What do you think is making mainstream music?
You think this was made by humans?
At some point enough data is gathered from a band to continue producing slop based on it forever.
Once good bands turning into pure shit parodies of themselves was a thing long before AI.
Sounds like a song created for a TV ads.
probably has something to do with even the latest gpt4 not being able to give you 5 sentences ending in 'apple'.
I think if you pursue let alone enjoy AI music you should have a nice day for being such a soulless smooth brain npc of a “person”. I think the same for anyone who partakes in any AI generated content.
Throwing out what attributes make you human, fine. Then to me you are no longer human. Eat shit and die, Black person.
All music in the last decade is "AI developed". Notice how it all becomes stale after 3 months. It's formulaic and optimized to harvest attention for a short period and then become entirely forgotten.
It's also created to have something to say on any kind of occasion through whatever lyrics.
>all music in the last decade
How to tell a motherfricker doesn’t actually listen to music, they just acknowledge the pop music trends.
You probably listen to Taylor Swift.
Music is already extremely oversaturated.